New York Style Pizza

Enjoy authentic New York Style Pizza at our Cincinnati location! Fresh, delicious slices crafted with traditional recipes. Visit us at 4927 Reading Rd or call +1 513-242-2444 for orders.

Welcome to New York Style Pizza

Taste the Difference.

New York Style Pizza
New York Style Pizza
New York Style Pizza
New York Style Pizza

New York Style Pizza in Cincinnati serves classic, authentic flavors inspired by the bustling pizzerias of New York City. Located at 4927 Reading Rd, this beloved local spot offers a diverse menu with options that cater to every taste and craving. From mouthwatering pizzas to hearty sandwiches, New York Style Pizza brings an East Coast flair right to the heart of Cincinnati. Whether dining in, picking up, or ordering delivery, patrons enjoy a relaxed atmosphere perfect for families, friends, or solo lunch breaks. With an average meal price around $5.50, customers appreciate both the quality and the value. The union of flavors and vibrant community feel makes every visit special.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

4927 Reading Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45237, United States

Phone

+1 513-242-2444

About

The Culinary Story

New York Style Pizza
New York Style Pizza
New York Style Pizza
New York Style Pizza

New York Style Pizza stands out in Cincinnati for its commitment to delivering authentic New York flavors without the need for travel. This restaurant is more than just a pizzeria; it offers a rich tapestry of culinary delights that draw inspiration from New York's diverse dining scene. The menu features well-loved items such as gyros, chicken sandwiches, and classic burgers alongside signature seafood family meals and tantalizing desserts. Each dish offers a unique taste experience, and the variety means there's something for everyone, whether you're dining solo or with family.

One highlight is the family meals, which serve as a wonderful option for gatherings. The flexibility allows diners to choose any three items from their seafood selections, catering to those with mixed preferences.

The restaurant enjoys a loyal customer base, thanks largely to its commitment to quality and affordability. Regulars rave about the inviting atmosphere, making it a preferred gathering spot for locals. People often mention the reliable service and friendly staff, which keeps the experience warm and personal.

For those craving a taste of the coast, New York Style Pizza embraces the community spirit by engaging with local events and enjoying a regular flow of customer feedback to refine their offerings. Many local businesses flock to New York Style Pizza for lunch breaks or takeout orders between the hustle of work schedules. This commitment to the community—combined with a delicious menu and fair pricing—helps the restaurant thrive amidst Cincinnati's culinary landscape.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

The features at New York Style Pizza ensure every visit delivers satisfaction. The extensive menu boasts 46 dishes spanning various categories, including New York Style sandwiches, family meals, sides, desserts, and beverages. Highlights include the Chicken Cheese Steak Sandwich, double cheeseburger, and the delectable fried seafood options like tilapia and catfish. Each dish is crafted with fresh ingredients reflecting the vibrant flavors of NYC.

Whether you're looking for a quick bite or a family feast, the flexible pricing accommodates every budget, with many items under $5.

The cozy interior and friendly staff contribute to an inviting atmosphere. The restaurant seamlessly blends casual dining with the ambiance of a New York deli. With generous portion sizes and quick service, it stands as a local favorite for anyone craving a taste of the Big Apple.

New York Style Pizza

The exterior of New York Style Pizza captures the essence of a bustling New York eatery, with vibrant signage that beckons pizza lovers from afar. Nestled on Reading Road, the location enjoys great visibility while also creating a charming, accessible vibe. The casual outdoor seating invites diners to enjoy their meals alfresco, soaking up the community's vibrancy and urban atmosphere. This welcoming approach fosters a gathering spot for families and friends alike, encouraging a sense of belonging. The restaurant exudes charm and warmth, carrying a hint of the classic New York scene blended with the comforting familiarity of home.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Good food and Halal. Their Philly Steak pizza is awesome.

N
Nauman M.

I've been going here for a year&to hear that they are closing is heartbreaking because they are like family to me an a lot of others,,I love the food an hoping for a new location to be opening up soon,,I love u guys

M
Michelle B.

Incredible food, friendly service. Absolutely amazing experience! Will be returning weekly.... Or daily...

K
Kyle T.

Love the fried fish (whiting ),pizza, & chicken hoagie! OPEN LATE!

M
MaLeisa L.

The food is good

T
Tonio S.